The drive towards building inclusive workplaces with equitable opportunities and truly diverse teams is often treated as a matter of compliance, positive PR, or a modest side-project for HR. Yet, if approached in this way, through quotas, optics, or isolated gestures, it will fail to deliver on its true potential for propelling business growth, creating high-performing teams, and building environments where people thrive. There is a pressing need to move beyond surface-level initiatives, embracing DEI not as an optional extra, but as a core and strategic commitment to fairness.
The experience of the modern workplace, especially in sectors such as financial services and fintech, illustrates a paradox. While these industries fuel innovation with cutting-edge technology, many still struggle to evolve beyond traditional approaches to recruitment, progression, and retention. The consequence is missed talent, stifled innovation, and corporations that simply do not reflect their customer base or society at large.
The Emotional Weight and Urgency of DEI
Those who have worked at the sharp end of the DEI journey know that this is not an emotionally neutral space, nor can it be tackled with a tick-box mentality. Driving change in attitudes, challenging ingrained perspectives, and opening organisational eyes to overlooked talent is often a deeply personal and demanding experience for those leading the charge. Such advocacy is underpinned by a deeply rooted sense of fairness and a sharp awareness of the disadvantages (often silent and systemic) that keep certain groups at the margins.
Personal experiences, such as starting out in industries where no one around looks like you, where representation is close to negligible, are powerful catalysts. They cultivate an unshakeable commitment to ensuring others do not have to navigate the workplace as solitary outsiders, doubting whether they belong or will be heard. Yet, those early experiences are not unique, they echo in the stories of many women and minorities who, although present in talent pipelines, struggle to progress or remain in sectors that are slow to change.
It’s not enough to attract a diverse workforce if inclusion efforts peter out at the onboarding stage. Retention, progression, fair access to stretch assignments, and the courage to promote those who challenge our perspectives, these are the true measures of progress. In practice, this means tackling the insidious effects of microaggressions, the completeness of decision data, and the composition of promotion panels. These are the seams where businesses subtly reinforce bias or fairness.
Evidence-Led Action: Turning Anecdote into Strategic Advantage
There’s nothing more frustrating for a professional recruiter or talent specialist than observing the same patterns of disadvantaged outcomes being excused with subjective or simplistic justifications, “not the right fit”, “not quite the technical match”. Over time, these explanations ring increasingly hollow. The value of a DEI lens in recruitment lies in looking beneath the surface, gathering evidence at scale, and converting private conversations and data into actionable insight for leadership.
After witnessing thousands of interviews, both successful and unsuccessful, over the years, the seasoned talent advisor is in a unique position. Patterns and trends emerge, making it abundantly clear that something is systemically awry. It is only with the confidence built from years of observing, listening, and collecting nuanced evidence that one can challenge prevailing narratives and drive leaders to confront the uncomfortable truth: too often, it is the system, not the individual, that is broken.
Indeed, as this approach matures, data leads the way. Bringing numbers to the leadership table, such as quantifying the real reasons women or underrepresented professionals exit businesses, acts as both a shield and a catalyst. Leaders can, and do, challenge anecdote; it is far harder to dismiss robust analysis. In doing so, recruiters and talent professionals can elevate their function, pushing organisations to take sustained, evidence-led steps that put humanity and fairness at the centre of talent strategy.
The Business Case for Inclusive Recruitment
Many businesses are tempted to treat DEI as an add-on to traditional recruitment: a nice-to-have, or a campaign launched in times of public scrutiny. But the true commercial impact goes broader and deeper. Recruitment done inclusively is recruitment done well. It is more than another string to the bow; it is the core of strategy.
There is now strong data to connect a DEI-centred recruitment approach with real revenue impact and long-term relationships. When businesses are rigorous in tracking the origin of their opportunities, identifying where clients first engage, why they return, and how relationships blossom, it often becomes clear that those drawn to the brand are motivated by its authentic stance on fairness, its investment in people, and its work to foster inclusive cultures.
Brands that position themselves at the forefront of gender-balanced talent pools, celebrate progressive industry shifts, and actively change perceptions are those that attract not just talent, but the best kind of clients, ones who are looking for genuine partners for positive change rather than the latest trend or cheapest deal. By focusing on collective progress and celebrating small wins, companies also retain people far better and build reputational value that pays off with every introduction and new client.
Practical Steps for Businesses at Any Stage
It is often said in DEI circles that “you have to listen to your people”. In practice, this is easier said than done. Listening is not just about conducting yet another survey and letting the results disappear into the ether. The way you listen, whether through employee groups, one-to-ones, anonymous feedback loops, or informal check-ins, matters. Do your people feel safe to speak? Do they believe you’ll act? Have they seen you act before? If not, the process needs overhauling.
Meaningful engagement must be continual, transparent, and followed by visible action. Leaders are wise to update teams on the progress and hurdles in implementing suggested changes, no matter how small or incomplete. Overlooking this step risks eroding trust even further. A sure-fire way to lose talented staff who believe their voice is ignored.
Celebration is another underappreciated tool for retention and morale. Industry culture tends to focus on drama and failure, yet organisations that consciously spotlight what is working, who is thriving, and where positive shifts are happening play a vital role in shifting mindsets. Role models, positive case studies, and stories of successful change give hope and practical proof that workplaces truly can evolve.
Challenging the Archaic Application Process
Recruitment itself is ripe for transformation. Relying on written job descriptions posted online, followed by hackneyed processes of sifting through CVs to spot those who have “done it before”, is increasingly out of step with the needs of modern businesses. AI may sift more resumes than ever, but the logic governing those algorithms is often even more entrenched in conventional thinking.
Whilst more refined employer branding, storytelling on company websites, staff spotlights, and high-profile participation at industry events, does help, it is not the whole answer. There remains a fundamental disconnect if companies, despite their best efforts, claim “diverse candidates just don’t apply here”. The issue most often lies with the process itself.
Businesses should embrace creativity in surfacing talent from new avenues, looking beyond direct repetition of roles on a CV. Transferable skills, motivation, and readiness for challenge are better predictors of long-term value than checkboxes of previous experience. Overhauling job design, actively reaching into different pools, and even transforming who represents the firm on public stages can shift perception and application rates dramatically.Â
Dispelling Common Myths: DEI is Never a ‘One and Done’
Perhaps the most dangerous misconception is that hiring for diversity can be solved with one intervention, a quota, a round of “blind recruitment”, or tweaking the language on job descriptions. Such approaches might look good in board papers, but without the surrounding culture of support, those hired are likely to struggle, feel undermined, or exit quickly.
The other myth is that the job can fall to one person or even a small team, “the inclusion officer will sort it”. True inclusion requires participation at all levels, making it core to business transformation, not a siloed initiative.
In extreme cases, some organisations, in the absence of quick wins from targeted DEI spending, simply revert to doing nothing at all, abandoning any attempt to shift the dial. This is guaranteed to consign the business to irrelevance, missing blind spots lurking in product design, customer experience, or team cohesion, which only become apparent when it’s too late. The world and customer base are diverse organisations that fail to reflect this will inevitably falter.
Cultivating Positive Debate and Avoiding ‘Groupthink’
Another key learning for growing businesses is the value of positive debate. There is a certain comfort in convening rooms full of like-minded professionals who reach swift consensus. Yet, if ten people agree on everything, it is likely something important has been missed. True progress happens when challenge is welcomed.
Leaders must actively seek and create environments where differing voices are heard and valued. A culture of constructive debate where disagreement is not only tolerated but encouraged powers learning, exposes blind spots, and generates genuinely new ideas. This requires courage from leadership and psychological safety throughout an organisation, but its returns are immense: companies that foster such debate outstrip their competitors in agility, creativity, and resilience.
Final Thoughts
Embedding principles of fairness, equity, and inclusion into business is not a modal shift or a single campaign, but a multi-layered, ongoing journey. It requires constant listening, visible celebration of progress, humility to act on feedback, and a willingness to challenge outdated processes at every stage.
When this is done well, the impact is commercial as much as it is cultural. Teams perform better, innovative thinking abounds, clients gravitate towards brands living their values, not just paying lip service and, crucially, everyone is given space to grow.
The businesses that will thrive in an increasingly complex, connected, and diverse world are those that make inclusion and fairness both their north star and their daily practice. That is where sustained growth, relevance, and high performance will always be found.
—
This post is inspired by the full and wide-ranging discussion on DEI in fintech and broader industry, as explored in our latest episode of Beyond Break Even. For further insights and practical takeaways from sector leaders, tune in to Episode 7: The DEI Download – On a Mission for Equity, Inclusivity, and Diversity.
